News • 27.12.2019

Security in payment

Study shows credit card industry has ignored security innovations

Paying with creditcard via internet
Source: Bildagentur PantherMedia / dedivan1923

A new study conducted for the Secure Payments Partnership coalition shows that the U.S. credit card industry has failed to establish adequate security standards and that a neutral third party should be put in charge, the National Retail Federation said today.

“Millions of Americans have experienced credit card fraud and that’s unacceptable,” NRF Senior Vice President and General Counsel Stephanie Martz said. “Our payments system should be the strongest and most secure in the world, but we won’t get there unless we change the way we set security standards. This study shows that the card industry has repeatedly ignored innovations that could have given us a more secure system, and that cannot be allowed to continue. NRF remains committed to continuing our work with the card companies to find lasting solutions that will protect businesses and consumers alike.”

SPP today released “Payment Insecurity: How Visa and Mastercard Use Standard-Setting to Restrict Competition and Thwart Payment Innovation[CS1] ,” an in-depth study of EMVCo, an organization owned by the world’s six largest payment card companies that sets technical specifications for credit, debit and other payment cards. Conducted by the Retail Payments Global Consulting Group industry research firm, the report highlights a systemic pattern of decision-making by EMVCo that has put in place standards with diminished security that have led to increased fraud risk. Doing so has helped those card companies dominate the payments market, according to the report.

What the report concludes

The 55-page paper concludes that the leadership of EMVCo has prioritized card companies’ market share over security, driven up costs for businesses and consumers and left the United States with a fraud-prone payment system that lags behind security standards in international markets. EMVCo claims to produce only technical “specifications” needed to ensure interoperability, but those specifications become de facto standards with implications far beyond technical compatibility. Because EMVCo is run by the major card companies, it is not an appropriate organization to develop standards with such widespread impact on the U.S. payments system, the paper says.

The report recommended that standards-setting be shifted from EMVco to a neutral national or international standard-setting body. The report shows:

  • Visa and MasterCard dominate EMVCo and ensure that it sets standards they can use to beat competitors. 
  • EMVCo bolstered Visa’s 20-year-plus battle against allowing retailers to process transactions through competitors’ debit networks, resulting in the implementation of less-secure chip-and-signature EMV cards in the United States rather than the chip-and-PIN cards used in most of the rest of the world.
  • EMVCo adopted expensive, complex and difficult-to-implement technology such as near-field communication because it prevents competitors from entering the mobile payments market.
  • EMVCo adopted an anticompetitive tokenization standard that discriminates against debit networks and non-card forms of payment.
  • EMVCo ignored the work of other organizations such as the Fast Identity Online Alliance and World Wide Web Consortium in developing open standards for authentication that would have allowed competitors into the system.
  • EMVCo has introduced the Secure Remote Commerce standard, which purports to become a new integrated checkout platform for online payments but could make it difficult to route transactions through competitors’ debit networks, create higher dependence on the card companies and increase merchants’ payment processing costs.

EMVCo and the card companies have routinely dismissed innovations and new standards to maintain their dominance, according to the study. The paper highlights how EMVCo says its specifications promote “compatibility,” “interoperability” and “secure transactions” but contradicts these concepts with its own practices.

Quelle: National Retail Federation

related articles:

popular articles:

Thumbnail-Photo: Which businesses should be open?
17.06.2020   #brick and mortar retail #coronavirus

Which businesses should be open?

MIT study looks at tradeoffs between economic value and public health, across different types of retail

Banks and bookstores. Gyms and juice bars. Dental offices and department stores. The Covid-19 crisis has shuttered some kinds of businesses, while others have stayed open. But which places represent the best and worst tradeoffs, in terms of the ...

Thumbnail-Photo: The importance of effective complaint management...
12.08.2020   #customer satisfaction #customer relationship management

The importance of effective complaint management

A strategic and cross-channel approach to handling negative customer experiences

Customers are more demanding than ever, while brand loyalty is declining. Even a couple of negative experiences can alienate consumers and erode loyalty. Shoppers increasingly share bad reviews and complaints on public communication channels for ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Come together: local retailers connect with local customers...
15.09.2020   #brick and mortar retail #customer relationship management

Come together: local retailers connect with local customers

The online platform connects local retailers with potential customers. The common denominator: A product.

How can you bridge the gap and connect online retail to pedestrian zones? A Nuremberg startup wondered how this could be accomplished and came up with a solution: In this interview, founder Matthias Hueber talks about the idea behind ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Sustainability is surviving COVID-19
27.07.2020   #sustainability #coronavirus

Sustainability is surviving COVID-19

Trends and consumer demographics for sustainable products and brands

The NYU Stern Center for Sustainable Business and IRI® published the results of new research examining consumer purchases of sustainability-marketed consumer packaged goods in the US and taking a closer look at the top 10 states in terms of per ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Retailers say credit insurance plan could increase liquidity during...
15.07.2020   #retail #coronavirus

Retailers say credit insurance plan could increase liquidity during pandemic downturn

Backstop for trade credit insurance

The National Retail Federation welcomed a report released this week calling for a federal backstop for trade credit insurance, saying the proposal could help provide liquidity badly needed by retailers as they recover from the recession brought on ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Grocery consumers increasingly anxious about rising food prices...
31.08.2020   #customer satisfaction #customer analysis

Grocery consumers increasingly anxious about rising food prices

U.S. had the largest increase of any country in the dunnhumby Worry Index, corresponding to strong uptick in U.S. COVID-19 cases

dunnhumby, the global leader in customer data science, today released findings from a multi-phased, worldwide study of the impact of COVID-19 on customer attitudes and behavior. The dunnhumby Consumer Pulse Survey found that the U.S. ...

Thumbnail-Photo: William Davidson Award for publication in the field of retail research...
25.06.2020   #digitization #shopping habits

William Davidson Award for publication in the field of retail research

Award-winning article identifying five different customer journey segments

Oliver Emrich, Professor of Management and Social Media at Johannes Gutenberg University Mainz (JGU), has been awarded the prestigious William R. Davidson Award for a publication in the field of retail research.Entitled "Loyalty Formation for ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Please give us shopping, events, and emotions!...
15.09.2020   #online trading #customer satisfaction

Please give us shopping, events, and emotions!

What should cities do to attract more visitors?

Online retail, coronavirus pandemic, monotony – city centers are fighting many battles these days. But although times might be tough for brick-and-mortar businesses, all is not lost when it comes to pedestrian zones.However, retailers should ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Better customer care on Twitter leads to increase in customer...
18.09.2020   #customer satisfaction #customer relationship management

Better customer care on Twitter leads to increase in customer satisfaction

Responses to queries on social media impact service quality perception

Social media has forever changed our society and how people do business. A 2013 report by J.D. Power found nearly two-thirds of customers have used a company's social media site to connect with customer service. New research in the INFORMS ...

Thumbnail-Photo: AfterPay: Survey on the shopping behaviour of Germans...
20.07.2020   #online trading #e-commerce

AfterPay: Survey on the shopping behaviour of Germans

German consumers will make a larger share of their purchases online in July

AfterPay Insights’ end of June research – now covering more 7.400 interviews with German online shoppers – indicates that German consumers will reduce their overall purchases in July. But at the same time, German consumers say ...