Field report • 05.08.2019

Mobile payments at the supermarket checkout

An early adopter’s experience of mobile payments

Or: "What’s that you’re doing with your watch?“

I still remember the first time I used mobile payment technology and paid for items with my smartphone at a supermarket checkout: It was October 17, 2018, exactly seven days after Google and PayPal announced that users can now add PayPal as a payment method on Google Pay on their phones. Until then, you could only use Google Pay in Germany with a handful of credit cards. The partnership with PayPal suddenly made it possible for Android users to add their bank account as their digital wallet without the need for a credit card or cooperation of their bank.

Mobile screenshot of Google Maps with shops and a location pin...
In the Google Pay app, it is possible to trace exactly where the payment was made - down to the meter.
Source: Maximilian Obenaus

Cashless payments for small transaction amounts

I chose a major real,- supermarket in an eastern neighborhood of Karlsruhe to make my first purchase. Armed with a handful of products worth 6.77 euros, I made my way to the self-checkout machine. I scanned the items and touched the "credit card payment" button. I unlocked my smartphone and held it close to the payment terminal screen, excited to see what would happen next. Just a few seconds later, my phone made a familiar two-tone sound and the receipt came out of the terminal’s printer. The robotic voice of the self-checkout instructed me to "please take your receipt and purchases. Thank you for visiting real,- market.’ Could payment really be this simple? I left the checkout area with the proud and confident swagger of an “early adopter”. My smartphone had two more notifications for me: Both the Google Pay app and an e-mail from PayPal confirmed my purchase and that payment was sent.

In the past, the practice of paying small amounts with your credit card was frowned upon. Many retailers would actually not accept payments under ten euros. Things have certainly changed. A couple of days ago I shopped at Lidl and only needed some carrots and some lettuce. Every cash register featured a big sign overhead urging shoppers to "please use your credit card for small purchases!" I used my credit card to pay the 1.50 euros I owed and this time I didn’t get a look of disapproval at the checkout.

Apart from the benefit that I no longer have to carry so much cash with me wherever I go, there is also an added safety aspect. If you pay with cash, you also have to make frequent trips to the ATM. Unfortunately, they are increasingly prone to manipulation. My ATM card has been repeatedly compromised and my number cloned and fraudulently used several times. Meanwhile, transactions can be instantly tracked via the corresponding app, allowing you to immediately report any fraudulent activities.

Mobile screenshot with payment confirmation and blue sea on Google Maps...
Ever paid mobile on a ship? That worked right away on the "Sassnitz". The location was also accurately placed in the sea.
Source: Maximilian Obenaus
"Available payment methods determine whether I buy things at a store." (Maximilian Obenaus)

Pay with your smartwatch

I always try to pay with my mobile device. Apart from my smartphone, I also own a Garmin Vivoactive 3 smartwatch, which includes an NFC chip. Both Garmin Pay and Fitbit Pay are makers of fitness watches and trackers with models that allow you to add account and payment information on your device to facilitate contactless payments.

Since only a few users presently use the pay feature on their smartwatches, there is currently no bank that supports Garmin Pay in Germany. Only FinTech’s VIMpay and boon. by Wirecard afford the opportunity to set up a virtual prepaid MasterCard via their respective app, which can then be stored for Garmin Pay use. But first you have to top up the debit card to draw funds for payments. Thanks to automatic top-up, this is not perceived as a drawback. The boon service costs € 1.49 a month. I currently use its virtual MasterCard on my Vivoactive 3. It’s worth the fee because it allows me to pay with my smartwatch. That’s handy when I go jogging, left my smartphone and wallet in the car and quickly want to buy some milk for example.

“Contactless payment terminals": popularity among the retail sector 

Mobile payment services are possible wherever credit cards are accepted and credit card terminals are NFC equipped. At this point, almost all retailers provide this option. Even our corner store features new terminals. I don’t know of any grocery or department stores in the Karlsruhe area that don’t offer contactless and mobile payment services.

Sign on a glass door with the inscription We are going cashless....
What is still unimaginable in Germany is already reality in Scandinavia: shops that no longer accept cash.
Source: Maximilian Obenaus

Things are somewhat more difficult when it comes to German pharmacies, small specialty stores or hair salons for example. These types of stores still tend to rely on cash or debit cards. I recently went to my favorite bakery and they could not make change. The sales assistant practically kicked me out of the store when I suggested they should consider offering modern payment methods. Alas, I no longer shop there. And indeed, I am also changing my buying patterns: Available payment methods determine whether I buy things at a store.

How well does the technology work?

So far, I have completed at least a hundred mobile payment transactions. Not once did I encounter a technical issue. Each transaction was always simple and smooth with no problems. I also never had any issues where the amount was wrong or things were deducted twice or not at all. That’s also owing to Google Pay’s pragmatic implementation.

By contrast, my wife uses an iPhone and Apple Pay. Unfortunately, she often runs into problems: Some research revealed that older wireless terminals still use a network protocol that is considered obsolete and might also be less secure. Google still supports it but Apple does not. Other countries like the U.S. no longer allow the use of the obsolete protocol. Many German stores still use the old terminals. For example, if you want to pay at a Globus hypermarket checkout, note that Google Pay works perfectly fine, while Apple Pay does not.

Sales staff and customer reactions

With the subject still in its infancy in Germany, reactions can vary significantly. It's quite easy to strike up a conversation about mobile payments with customers waiting in line behind me. They often confess that they have heard about mobile payment solutions but they have never actually seen anyone use these options.

Some cashiers are puzzled and ask me: "What’s that you’re doing with your watch?“ They are totally baffled when the cash drawer suddenly opens and the receipt confirms that payment has been received. To stop cashiers who are not yet familiar with mobile payment options from having a panic attack and worrying about which button they should press, I simply say, “I am paying with my credit card.”

Author: Maximilian Obenaus

related articles:

popular articles:

Thumbnail-Photo: Leveraging your retail strengths with digitization and automation...
16.02.2020   #consulting #brick and mortar retail

Leveraging your retail strengths with digitization and automation

Oliver Voßhenrich of POS Tuning talks about EuroShop 2020 and the promise of process optimization

Retailers have to make multiple decisions every day as it pertains to the point of sale (POS) according to the managing director of POS Tuning. He explains how digitization and automation help the industry to minimize manual processes and free up ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Password? No need!
09.03.2020   #mobile payment #security

Password? No need!

Interview with Dr. Daniel Schellenberg, COO of IDEE GmbH

Do you have an existing user account? Did you forget your password? No doubt, those are some annoying questions when you shop online. The brains behind IDEE agree and leverage your "digital identity" to make surfing and online shopping ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Wireless with SVN-Flex from SALTO
20.01.2020   #security #security management

Wireless with SVN-Flex from SALTO

SALTO has launched SVN-Flex, a new technology that enables virtual networked access control solutions

In the solutions wireless electronic escutcheons and cylinders act as wire-free updaters. This leads to greater efficiency, security and convenience.The innovation of the SVN-Flex is that users no longer necessarily need hard-wired wall readers to ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Successful local grocery store: Here is the recipe...
10.01.2020   #electronic shelf labels (ESL) #food retail

Successful local grocery store: Here is the recipe

Fast price adjustment with electronic shelf labels

Many small local grocery stores have difficulty getting a profitable business, but in the Danish cottage area between Nymindegab and Hvide Sande, the local Min Købmand store in Bjerregaard has found the recipe to be successful. Now, the ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Cloud access control for retail companies
27.01.2020   #security #security management

Cloud access control for retail companies

SALTO KS Keys as a Service: Manage access wire-free and in real-time

With SALTO KS Keys as a Service, all types of wholesalers and retailers, chain restaurants and banks can manage access to all shops, locations, offices and warehouses/storage rooms wire-free and in real-time. This enhances loss prevention, helps to ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Light up the future with Posiflex at EuroShop 2020...
11.02.2020   #kiosk terminals #Trade fair special EuroShop 2020

Light up the future with Posiflex at EuroShop 2020

Serviced IoT solutions: personalized, flexible and connected

The Posiflex Group, a synergy of world-leading POS, kiosk, and industrial computing technologies — will bring its Serviced IoT solutions to EuroShop 2020, the leading Europe trade fair for the retail industry, from February 16th – 20th ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Online payment fraud losses to exceed $200 billion...
02.03.2020   #online trading #mobile payment

Online payment fraud losses to exceed $200 billion

Ongoing high level of data breaches and fraud innovation driving losses

A new study from Juniper Research has found that businesses in e-commerce, airline ticketing, money transfer and banking services, will cumulatively lose over 200 billion dollars to online payment fraud between 2020 and 2024, driven by the increased ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Consumer survey: social distancing is changing shopping habits...
10.04.2020   #brick and mortar retail #payment systems

Consumer survey: social distancing is changing shopping habits

Touchless or self-checkout options preferred for instore shopping during COVID-19 pandemic

Nearly two-thirds of consumers are changing their grocery shopping habits in response to the worldwide COVID-19 pandemic, according to a recent consumer survey from Shekel, pioneers in advanced weighing technologies. And 87 percent of shoppers say ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Cutting through the tax jungle
25.02.2020   #online trading #e-commerce

Cutting through the tax jungle

Startup helps online retailers to be fully compliant with European VAT regulations

Anyone who sells goods online is obliged to pay value-added tax (VAT). The amount depends on the respective national regulations. But what happens if you have cross-border exports and transactions? How much VAT do sellers have to pay in this case ...

Thumbnail-Photo: Compact for security
17.01.2020   #security #shopfitting

Compact for security

A new security antenna system specifically designed for convenience stores

Retail security systems to prevent theft are a big concern for retailers. Large supermarkets and clothing stores install EAS antennas at the entrance and/or exit areas. Installing this type of feature proves more challenging for stores with a ...

Supplier

Nagarro Allgeier ES GmbH
Nagarro Allgeier ES GmbH
Westerbachstr. 32
61476 Kronberg im Taunus
HappyOrNot
HappyOrNot
Innere Kanalstraße 15
50823 Köln
APG Cash Drawer (Germany)
APG Cash Drawer (Germany)
Leichtmetallstr. 22a
42781 Haan-Gruiten
POSIFLEX GmbH
POSIFLEX GmbH
Flinger Broich 203
40235 Düsseldorf
APG Cash Drawer
APG Cash Drawer
4 The Drove
BN9 0LA Newhaven
StrongPoint
StrongPoint
Isafjordsgatan 5
164 40 Kista
VR Payment GmbH
VR Payment GmbH
Saonestraße 3a
60528 Frankfurt am Main
Diebold Nixdorf
Diebold Nixdorf
Heinz-Nixdorf-Ring 1
33106 Paderborn
Burkhardt Leitner Modular Spaces GmbH
Olgastrasse 138
70180 Stuttgart
Adasys GmbH – a Poindus Company
Adasys GmbH – a Poindus Company
Max-Planck-Straße 10
70806 Kornwestheim